When Couples Counselling Isn't the Right Fit (Yet)
Sometimes I have to say no to couples therapy. It's one of the hardest parts of my job. I know how much courage it takes to reach out, and that many couples arrive feeling vulnerable and wanting the very best support.
But I believe being a good clinician means following best practice and the research, and doing what I believe is right by both of you. Sometimes the most caring thing I can say is "no” or “not yet". Couples therapy works best when both people can show up safely and honestly, and there are a few situations where that just isn't possible.
I like to be open and transparent about how I practise and why. So if you've been wondering whether couples counselling is right for you, I hope this post helps. None of what follows is about judgement. It's about making sure you get the right support, in the right order, so that if you do come to couples work, it has a real chance of helping.
How I make this decision
Every couple at Brisbane Couples Counselling starts with a thorough assessment, and part of that is checking whether couples therapy is a good fit. I listen carefully to both of your perspectives and take them into account. Ultimately, though, I make the call based on what I believe is clinically best for you both.
If I decide not to go ahead, for whatever reason, here's what you can expect:
An early call. I'll do my best to make the decision as early in the process as possible, to save you time and money.
An honest explanation. I'll explain my reasoning as best I can to you both.
Referral options. I'll suggest services or clinicians who can support you with what you need right now.
A warm handover. Where you both consent, I'm happy to speak with your new clinicians directly, so you don't have to start from scratch.
And hey, you might not agree with me, or you might even think I've got it wrong. I get that, and that's okay. Whatever happens, I want you to understand how and why I've made the call. I’m happy to explain and talk it out with you.
Here are the most common reasons couples therapy might not be the right fit, at least for now.
1. An affair that's still going
I work with affair recovery all the time, and couples can absolutely heal after infidelity. But that healing needs the affair to have ended. If the affair is still ongoing, the hurt partner is being asked to rebuild trust while the betrayal is still happening. That's like trying to set a broken bone while it's still being broken.
If you're the partner who's been involved with someone else and you're unsure whether to end it, individual counselling can be a really good place to sort through that honestly. Once the affair has ended, we can begin the work of atonement, attunement and rebuilding together.
2. Domestic and family violence, especially if a DVO is in place
Couples therapy asks both people to be open and vulnerable with each other. When one person is afraid of the other, that openness can put them at greater risk, both in the room and afterwards at home. Something said honestly in a session can be used against someone later.
The Gottman Method, which I use, treats ongoing violence as a reason not to do couples therapy when there's a clear perpetrator, the violence is used to control, and one partner is afraid. Denying, minimising, blaming the partner, or avoiding responsibility for abuse are also reasons couples therapy isn't appropriate.
If there is a Domestic Violence Order (DVO) in place, joint sessions are not appropriate. Depending on its conditions, attending together might even breach the order. In these situations, the safest path is individual support for each person, with specialist services that understand domestic and family violence.
If you feel unsafe in your relationship, you deserve support. Please reach out to one of the services listed at the end of this post. If you’re using violence in your relationship, you also need individual support and a way to change your behaviour.
3. Active addiction that needs treatment first
Addiction affects the whole relationship, and couples work can be a powerful part of recovery. But when an addiction to alcohol, drugs, gambling or anything else is active and untreated, it tends to take up all the space. It's very hard to build new relationship skills when one person isn't able to be fully present.
In most cases, the first step is getting the right treatment for the addiction. Once recovery is underway, couples counselling can help you both repair the impact on your relationship and support recovery together. I've completed specialist training in treating couples and addiction, and I love this stage of the work.
4. One partner has already decided to leave
Sometimes one person comes to counselling hoping to save the relationship, while the other has already made up their mind to leave. That's a really painful mismatch.
Couples counselling needs both people to be at least willing to try. If one of you is sure it's over, separation counselling or individual support may be more helpful. That can help you both end things with as much care and respect as possible, especially if you share children.
5. A mental health crisis
If one partner is experiencing a serious mental health crisis, such as thoughts of suicide or a severe episode of an untreated condition, that needs to come first. Couples therapy can stir up a lot. When someone is in crisis, individual and specialist mental health support is the priority. Couples work can come later, when there's more stability.
6. When therapy is being used to win
Occasionally, one partner wants couples counselling mainly to prove they're right, or to have a professional confirm that the other person is the problem. Sometimes it's used as a way to control or pressure a partner. Couples therapy isn't about deciding who wins. If that's the main goal, it's worth pausing to reflect on what you're really hoping for.
7. A conflict of interest
Sometimes, once we get started, it becomes clear I'm not the right person to work with you. This might be because:
• we share a mutual friend, or move in the same social, work or community circles
• I've previously seen one of you, a family member or an ex-partner for counselling
• there's a possible dual relationship, for example one of you is a neighbour, a colleague, or someone I know through a local group or business
• our professional paths are likely to cross regularly
Brisbane can feel like a big country town, so this happens more often than you might think! Couples therapy relies on you both trusting that I'm neutral and that what you share stays private. If there's a conflict of interest, even a small one, I'll let you know as soon as I'm aware of it and help you find someone just as good. It's not about anything you've done. It's about protecting your privacy and the integrity of your therapy.
If we meet for an assessment and I think couples counselling isn't the right fit yet, I'll tell you honestly and kindly. Where I can, I'll help point you towards support that suits where you are right now.
Support services
If you or someone you love needs support, these services can help:
Emergency: 000 if you're in immediate danger
1800RESPECT: 1800 737 732, national DFV and sexual assault counselling, 24/7
DVConnect Womensline (Qld): 1800 811 811, 24/7
DVConnect Mensline (Qld): 1800 600 636
Men's Referral Service (No to Violence): 1300 766 491, for men who want to change abusive behaviour, 24/7
Alcohol and Drug Information Service (Qld): 1800 177 833, 24/7
Lifeline: 13 11 14, crisis support, 24/7
Not sure if couples counselling is right for you?
You're very welcome to get in touch. I'm Michelle, and I run Brisbane Couples Counselling in Paddington, with telehealth available too. Every couple starts with a thorough assessment, so we can work out together what kind of support will help you most.



Comments